Short answer: To increase average order value (AOV), give shoppers a clear reason to add one more item: set a free-shipping or reward threshold 15–30% above your current AOV, offer bundles of products people already buy together, recommend relevant add-ons in the cart and right after purchase, and use tiered offers like "spend $100, get $25." Judge every tactic on revenue and margin per visitor, not AOV alone.
First, know your numbers
Average order value = total revenue ÷ number of orders. Pull these before you start:
- Current AOV for the last 90 days, excluding outliers like wholesale orders.
- Order value distribution: how many orders fall in each $10 or $25 band. Thresholds work best just above the most common band.
- Top product pairs: which items appear together most often.
- Gross margin per order: so you know how much a reward or free shipping can cost.
A tactic that raises AOV by $8 but costs $10 in shipping or discount is a loss. Always check margin.
Threshold tactics
1. Free-shipping threshold just above AOV
If most orders land between $50 and $60, set free shipping at $65 or $75. The shopper with $55 in the cart has a reason to add something small. Show the progress in the cart: "You're $12 away from free shipping."
2. Tiered rewards: "Spend $100, get $25"
A spend-and-get offer rewards bigger baskets directly. Set tiers from your distribution, for example:
| Cart value | Reward |
|---|---|
| $75+ | Free shipping |
| $100+ | $25 reward |
| $150+ | $25 reward + gift |
The reward doesn't have to be store credit. Store credit only pays off if they come back, and it's another discount. An experience reward, such as $25 toward concert, sports or Broadway tickets, feels bigger to the shopper and stands out from every other "spend and save" offer. (More on that below.)
3. Cart progress bars
Show one bar with the next milestone and what unlocks there. Seeing the gap closes it more often than a banner the shopper scrolled past.
Bundle tactics
4. Build bundles from real order data
Start with your most common product pairs. Name the bundle after the outcome ("The complete morning routine"), not the SKUs.
5. Price bundles with a visible saving
Show the separate total crossed out next to the bundle price. A modest saving is usually enough because the bundle also saves the shopper decisions.
6. Offer "build your own" bundles
Let shoppers pick 3 of 10 items at a set price. It raises item count while giving them control.
7. Use multi-packs for consumables
"Buy 3, save 10%" or a 3-pack for products people run out of. It raises AOV and delays the next purchase decision in your favor.
Upsell and cross-sell tactics
8. Upsell to the better version on the product page
Show the premium version with a clear one-line reason it's worth more ("2× the capacity, same size"). Keep it to one alternative.
9. Cross-sell complements in the cart
Recommend items that complete the purchase: the case for the device, the refill for the starter kit. Limit to two or three, priced well below the main item.
10. Post-purchase one-click upsell
Right after payment, on the thank-you page, offer a relevant add-on that can be added to the same shipment with one click. The buying decision is already made, so the friction is low.
11. Personalize recommendations
"Customers who bought this also bought" beats a generic best-seller row. Even simple rules based on category work.
Offer and pricing tactics
12. Gift with purchase above a threshold
"Spend $80, get a free travel-size" moves shoppers over the threshold and introduces a new product. Choose gifts with high perceived value and low cost. See gift with purchase alternatives for other options.
13. Volume pricing
Price breaks at two and three units for products people buy for others or use in multiples.
14. Anchor with a premium option
Showing a higher-priced option makes the middle option look reasonable. This works on product lines, bundles and subscription tiers alike.
15. Reward the bigger basket with an experience
This is where ticket incentives fit. With Get Live, a brand can offer "Spend $100, get $25 in tickets" toward 40,000+ events across major sports leagues, college sports, concerts, Broadway, theater and travel.
- You set the threshold and where the offer appears: product pages, cart, email, SMS, ads.
- Your brand sends the ticket code to the customer after the qualifying order.
- Get Live helps you implement the trigger, placement and copy.
In Get Live's own program data, conversions have been up to 40% higher with a ticket reward in the offer. Because it's tied to a threshold, it can lift AOV and conversion at the same time. Test it against your current threshold offer and compare revenue per visitor.
How to set your threshold: a worked example
Say your AOV is $68 and your order distribution peaks at $55–$70.
- Pick the threshold:about 25–30% above AOV, so $85–$90. Round to $85.
- Check reachability:do you have $15–$25 add-on items? If not, create one (accessories, refills, minis).
- Cost the reward:if the reward or shipping costs you $X, the extra margin from the added items has to cover it on the orders that would have happened anyway.
- Run the test:split traffic, run at least two full weeks, and compare revenue per visitor and gross margin per visitor.
- Watch the side effects:returns on add-on items, shipping costs and whether conversion rate dropped.
Where to show threshold and upsell offers
An offer only works if the shopper sees it at the moment of decision:
- Announcement bar: one line across every page of your website, with the threshold ("Spend $100, get $25 in tickets").
- Product page: under the price, so the shopper knows before adding to cart.
- Cart drawer and cart page: with a progress bar and two or three add-on suggestions priced to close the gap.
- Checkout: a short reminder of what they've unlocked, so nobody removes items at the last step.
- Email and SMS: abandoned-cart and browse-abandonment messages should restate the threshold.
- Post-purchase page and confirmation email: the one-click add-on and the reward confirmation.
AOV tactics by business type
Not every tactic fits every store. Start with the ones that match how your customers buy:
| Business type | Best first tactics | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Consumables (beauty, supplements, coffee, pet) | Multi-packs, subscribe-and-save, spend thresholds | Customers already plan to rebuy, so bigger baskets feel natural |
| Gifts and seasonal | Gift sets, gift with purchase, holiday thresholds | Shoppers are buying for several people at once |
| Apparel and accessories | Cart cross-sells, "complete the look" bundles | Complements are obvious and easy to show |
| High-ticket single items | Premium upsell, protection plans, post-purchase add-ons | One item per order, so the add-on is the lever |
| Subscription boxes | Add-on shop, annual prepay reward | The basket is fixed, so upgrades and prepay matter most |
Common AOV mistakes
- Thresholds set too high. If almost no one reaches it, it does nothing. Most shoppers should be within one item of it.
- Too many offers at once. Free shipping, a bundle, a gift and a discount in the same cart confuse people.
- Discount-only thinking. Every price cut has to be won back on volume. Rewards, gifts and bundles often hold margin better.
- Measuring AOV alone. Conversion can fall while AOV rises. Use revenue per visitor.
For the rest of the funnel, see our pillar guide on ecommerce conversion rate optimization.